Observer Response Journal Sheet
Note: These sheets can be duplicated to create students’ Observer-Response Journals.
Title of the Work: |
Artist’s Name: |
One image that stuck out to me from this work was
|
I chose this image because
|
Another image that stuck out to me in this work was
|
I chose this image because
|
These images/ideas help me realize
|
These images/ideas make me wonder about
|
Literature Lesson
Name____________________________________________________________
Objective: Students will be able to 1) complete a word analysis chart in order to analyze text-based vocabulary 2) answer reading comprehension questions in order to understand plot details in a speculative short story.
Warm Up: Imagine there is an apocalyptic event and you are one of the last two people on Earth. Who would you want the only other survivor to be and why? Describe this person how/why their presence would impact you.
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
|
Materials: Copies of W.E.B. DuBois’ The Comet, Reading Response Questions handout, Observer-Response Journals
Directions: Place students in small groups and assign each person a set of 4-6 vocabulary words. Have them complete the Word Analysis Chart for each of the vocabulary words. These charts can also be copied onto chart paper and completed as a group activity i.e. a gallery walk.
Vocabulary:
affably, cavern, fetid, reverberating, incrusted, peculiar, vast, methodically, groped, prostrate, giddily, hostelry, ravenously, stolidity, winnowed, prone, resolutely, haggard, bedraggled, inert, deftly, pall, somnolence, idle, chivalrous, suffused, solicitude
Word Analysis Chart
Name_____________________________________________________________
Directions: For each vocabulary word find 3 synonyms, 3 antonyms and write 1 sentence for each vocabulary word in the designated boxes.
Word:
Definition:
Synonyms
Antonyms
Sentence
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________ |
Word:
Definition:
Synonyms
Antonyms
Sentence
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________ |
Name_____________________________________________________
Guided Practice/Collaborative Practice-Reading Response Questions
For today’s lesson we will read “The Comet,” and as we read, please track the words and actions of Jim and Julia.
- What do we learn about how Jim feels about himself?
- What can you infer about Jim’s social status based on what we learn in the third full paragraph?
- What is the irony of Jim being sent down to the vaults by the president?
- What difference do you see in the description of the dead bodies in Manhattan versus those that are lying in the streets in Harlem?
- After they attempt to make contact with someone outside of New York City, what thoughts are running through Julia’s mind?
- After they return to the tower, how does Julia’s thoughts/attitude towards Jim begin to shift?
- Why does Julia describe Jim as the “great All-Father of the race to be”?
Summary Analysis: How does this short story by DuBois speculate about race and race relations in Jim and Julia’s New York. Please cite evidence from the text that supports your claim.
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
Art Lesson
Name___________________________________________________________________
Objective: Students will be able to engage in a collaborative discussion in order to analyze the social and political themes and symbols in Kehinde Wiley’s artwork.
Warm Up: (Note* Teacher should find an image(s) of Kehinde Wiley’s work to display for students to observe and write about.) Look at these images. Describe what you see and how aspects of this painting makes you feel. Use specific details from the image.
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
|
Materials: Kehinde Wiley: An Economy of Grace, reading handouts/organizer, images of Kehinde Wiley’s paintings
Guided Practice/Collaborative Practice
For today’s lesson, we will watch a documentary about the conceptualization of Kehinde Wiley’s art exhibit titled An Economy of Grace. Please complete the accompanying information tracker as we view the film to prepare for our collaborative discussion.
- What is significant about Wiley’s approach to his works of art? How does he recruit models for his portraits?
- How does Wiley situate his subjects in his works of art historically and culturally? Hint* What happens after he finds his models? How do the portraits get created?
- In An Economy of Grace, Wiley describes an exoticism that he sees in media culture. What is exoticized to him that is not so foreign?
- Why is the exhibit featured in this film unique? How is this group of paintings different from his other paintings?
- What political statement(s) is Wiley trying to make in creating paintings in the manner he does? How is his work innovative?
- What do we learn about the sociopolitical aspects of classic art?
- As you watch the film, make notes on the impact of participating in the creation of this exhibit has had on these women? How does this dismantle how they feel society sees them? What about this experience is liberating for Black people? This response should be in paragraph form. Use paraphrases that capture their feelings and thoughts.
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
|
- How has painting/art served as a medium of liberation for him personally?
- What is ironic about the fact that Wiley is soliciting a top fashion house to make the gowns for the shoot? How do some of the designers named by his staff make themselves off limits to large portions of the Black population?
- There is a moment in the film when the narrator describes the idea of haute couture being the state of being pristinely beautiful. In what ways do each of the women define or redefine that statement?
Woman #1
Woman #2
Woman #3
Woman #4
Woman #5
Reflection Question: How does Wiley’s work fit into the Black Speculative aesthetic?
Note to teacher* To save time in viewing, you may consider cutting the segment of the film from about 36:28-46:16. The portion of the film that shows the painting in China could be cut and not affect the lesson activities.
Music Lesson
Name__________________________________________________________________
Objective: Students will be able to make connections to texts and analyze images in Janelle Monae’s music.
Materials: Copies of Many Moons song lyrics, Many Moons music video, Many Moons audio recording, Observer-Response Journals, copies of additional Janelle Monae song lyrics and audio or video recordings (please see note below)
Warm Up: Consider the kind of music you have heard in your life. What purpose does music serve? What kinds of music are important to you and why?
Guided Practice/Collaborative Practice
During today’s class we will read the lyrics to Janelle Monae’s song Many Moons as we listen to the audio recording. Record your initial thoughts/responses to the song in your Observer-Response journal.
Now we will watch the music video for Many Moons. As we watch the video, take mental note of some of the images and words presented that stand out to you. Then respond to the following question:
What is the overall message of Monae’s song/video? Please be sure to cite evidence from the video and song lyrics to support your answer.
On your own, please read the lyrics of the selected Janelle Monae song as you listen to the audio recording. Highlight any interesting words or phrases that you encounter. Complete one page for this song and its lyrics in your Observer-Response journal. (I suggest Dance or Die and Q.U.E.E.N.)
Together we will watch excerpts of Janelle Monae’s emotion picture Dirty Computer. (Teachers, please note that this film cannot be shown without editing due to explicit/suggestive lyrics in some songs. The storyline between the songs should be shown along with select songs from the album. The suggested songs to include are Crazy, Classic Life and Americans from this album. Other songs may be screened and used in place of these choices at the teacher’s discretion.) After watching the film, add your reaction to your Observer-Response journal.
Lesson Plan-Film and TV
Name_________________________________________________________________
Objective: Students will be able to answer comprehension questions after comparing and contrasting characterization in literature and a television adaptation.
Materials: Black Lightning comics (for this lesson Numbers 6 & 7 were used but other volumes could be used also), Observer-response journal, Chart Paper, Markers, Tape
Warm Up: Please scan the copies of your Black Lightning comic book. Write down 3 “I see” statements and 3 “I wonder” statements. Turn and talk to your elbow partner and share one statement from each column. Each pair should be prepared to share your findings.
I See |
I Wonder |
I see
|
I wonder |
I see
|
I wonder |
I see
|
I wonder |
Guided Practice/Collaborative Work: We will read Black Lightning comic books in small groups. There should be one group for each character. Each group should select members of the group to be the recorder, the reporter, the materials assistant, the task manager, and the timekeeper by selecting one of the Group Role Cards. Each member should have only one of these roles.
Each group will read the given Black Lightning comic book, completing as much information as possible on your group’s assigned character. As you read, please complete the Character Chart for your given character (see Character Chart sheet below):
1) Jefferson Pierce
2) Black Lightning
3) Syonide
4) Tobias Whale
5) Peter Gambi
6) Lynn Stewart
7) Two Bits
All information learned from the comic book should be recorded in the left column. After conferring with your group please decide what information you will include collectively on the final draft of the character chart then transfer this information to the character chart that is to be recorded on the chart paper. This character chart will serve a resource for the class for the next lesson.
Once the final draft of the character chart is complete, please use the tape provided to hang your character chart in the designated area. Each reporter will present their group’s character in a 1-minute presentation.
After character chart presentations are completed, organize students into groups (the same reading groups could be used), and allow students who read different volumes of the Black Lightning series to add details about the characters to the left column of the charts (Gallery Walk).
*Note to teacher: Keep final drafts of charts posted in a designated area of the classroom for use in a subsequent lesson.
Group Role Cards
Directions: Print and copy these role cards. Cut them along the lines and
Task Manager
Keeps the group focused on the task so that the activity is completed.
|
Reporter
Presents the group’s ideas/findings to the whole group or class |
Recorder
Writes down or types the group’s ideas in whatever format has been assigned to the group.
|
Materials Assistant
Retrieves whatever materials are needed from the teacher in order for the group to complete the task. |
Time Keeper
Makes sure that the group completes the task in the allotted time. Reminds the group of how many minutes are left.
|
|
Black Lightning Character Cards
Directions: Please cut out each strip and provide one character card to each group.
Jefferson Pierce
|
Black Lightning
|
Syonide
|
Tobias Whale
|
Peter Gambi
|
Two Bits
|
Lynn Stewart
|
Character Chart
Directions: After reading the assigned comic book, complete the items below based on your understanding of the character from the text. This should be completed as each group member reads the assigned copy of their Black Lightning Comic.
Character’s Name:
|
Comic Series Attributes |
TV Series Attributes |
Character’s Occupation/Role in the story:
|
|
|
Character’s Actions
|
|
|
Character’s Thoughts/Emotions
|
|
|
*Note to teacher: This organizer will be used for the next lesson.
TV/Film Lesson
Objective: Students will be able to answer comprehension questions after comparing and contrasting characterization in literature and a television adaptation.
Materials: Character Charts (uses in previous lesson), Black Lightning TV Series Episodes, Final Draft of Chart Paper-Made Character Charts, Markers
Warm Up: In thinking about the fact that Black Lightning is DC Comics’ response to the changes in the sociopolitical landscape in the United States after the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and 1960s, is Black Lightning a sufficient Black superhero? Please explain your answer and provide a brief rationale to support your claim/opinion.
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________
|
Guided Practice/Collaborative Work: Using yesterday’s character charts, we will begin watching an “The Resurrection” episode of the Black Lightning television series adapted by Salim Akil and Mara Brock Akil. As you watch the episode, complete the right column of the organizer from yesterday’s class. After completing the organizer and conferring with your group, add the details from the television adaptation to the final draft of your character charts. Pay attention to the similarities and differences in the 40 year span from when the comic first launched and was crafted by Tony Isabella and Trevor Von Eeden and Salim Akil and Mara Brock Akil’s adaptation of the Black Lightning storyline and characters.
As you view the episodes, please add series-based character details to your character charts for your assigned character. In your previously assigned groups, update your larger, posted character charts created on chart paper in the previous lesson. Organize students into small groups to add new details based on the television series to the posted character charts.
As a whole group, the teacher and class will create a character chart for Anissa and Jennifer Pierce’s characters. Students will consider why the addition of these two female characters is significant/impactful.
Jennifer Pierce’s character is an addition to the Black Lightning DC comic storyline in 1996. Anissa Pierce’s character is an addition to the Black Lightning DC comic storyline in 2003.
- Why might comic creators have made the decision to include these characters in Black Lightning’s storyline?
- What do we know about Jennifer?
- What do we know about Anissa?
- How does their presence align with the concept of Afrofuturism/Black Speculative Art?
- In what ways do Anissa and Jennifer’s characters challenge the ideas of the traditional hero? In what ways do these characters give voice to marginalized, intersectional groups?
*Note to teacher: This lesson will likely take 2 class periods unless it is taught in a longer instructional block.
Unit Final Project
Using the works that we have studied in class over the course of this unit, you will create your own work of art in one of the following areas:
- Art- (drawing, painting, sculpture, collage, mosaic, textile)
- Literature-(poems, short stories, vignette)
- Film/Video-(short film, script/screenplay)
- Music-(song with or without lyrics)
For this assignment, you must incorporate elements of that particular genre into your original work that address the essential questions for the unit. After completing your work in the speculative/science fiction genre, you will write an expository essay that analyzes how your original work of speculative art connects to the essential questions (and their answers as you understand them) for the unit.
Unit Essential Questions
- How does race/racism impact Black speculative art and its subgenres?
- What are common elements of speculative and science fiction aesthetics?
- How can speculative and science fiction art serve as a means of liberation for marginalized people?
You should use your Observer-Response journal to include some of the identified elements in your work.
Questions to consider:
What message will your work of art send? What do you want your audience to understand/learn from your work
Rubric for Final Project
Category |
Exceptional |
Above Average |
Average |
Below Average |
Content |
The piece demonstrates a superior understanding of Black speculative/science fiction art and possesses clear and cohesive elements of the genre.
I used important details and information. I developed my ideas and made sure all of my sentences connected to the prompt.
|
The piece demonstrates an excellent understanding of Black speculative/science fiction art and possesses clear and cohesive elements of the genre.
I used some details to support my topic but I needed to add more information and supporting details. |
The piece demonstrates a solid understanding of Black speculative/science fiction art and possesses clear and cohesive elements of the genre.
I need to use more details to make my writing complete. |
The piece demonstrates a poor understanding of Black speculative/science fiction art and does not possess clear and cohesive elements of the genre.
I did not use details or ideas to support my topic or response. |
Focus |
My writing is clear and completely answers all parts of the prompt. I did not forget or lose the main idea when I added details.
|
Sometimes my writing moved away from the main point of focus of the prompt. Sometimes my details did not relate to the prompt and made my ideas confusing.
|
My writing is not clear and I drifted away from the prompt.
|
I did not stay focused on the topic or prompt. My writing is very difficult to understand when I re-read my work or when someone else reads my work. |
Organization |
I wrote a strong introduction, body, and conclusion. I used appropriate transitions to connect my ideas. |
I wrote an introduction. I need to strengthen all portions of my response. I need to use more transition words to make my ideas flow. |
I did not organize my response. I was missing key components of my paragraphs. My writing seems more like an outline than complete paragraphs. I did not use transition words. |
I had no clear introduction, body, or conclusion. I have many mixed-up ideas. I did not use transition words. |
Style |
I used descriptive words that help readers “see” my ideas. My sentences varied in length, word usage, and structure. My tone and voice are consistent. |
Most words address the prompt. I should choose a wider variety of words. I did not use different types of sentences. Tone and voice are not always consistent |
I used a few descriptive words. I had little sentence variety. The tone and voice are not consistent |
I used no descriptive words. My sentences all begin with the same word or are not complete. There is no consistent tone or voice. |
Conventions |
I had few, if any, errors in spelling, grammar, and punctuation. My writing is neat and legible. |
I made a few errors in spelling, grammar, and punctuation, but my meaning is still clear and understandable. |
I had many mistakes in spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Sometimes my writing is hard to read. |
My writing has so many mistakes that it is difficult to read or understand. |
Adapted in part from the “Student Friendly” PSSA Writing Rubric created by Methacton School District