Author: Diana KA Miller
School/Organization:
Henry H. Houston Elementary
Year: 2025
Seminar: Diverse Children's Literature: Literary Art, Cultural Artifact and Contested Terrain
Grade Level: K-5
Keywords: African American, authenticity, children’s literature, folktales, Jewish, mirrors & doors, multicultural, Muslim, picture books, Representation
School Subject(s): ELA, English, Social Studies
Too many times in elementary school classrooms, multicultural picture books are not closely examined for accuracy of the culture they are representing. Because multicultural picture books have a big impact on how elementary students perceive other cultures, it is vitally important to be as meticulous as possible when selecting these books. As a result of this course, I realized that I had fallen into the category of just picking pretty multicultural picture books for my students, while totally disregarding the impact said book would have on my pupils. Now, I select multicultural books that are authentic to that particular culture. And not just one, but multiple books to represent different aspects of that culture. My classroom activities included reading books about African American, Muslim, and Jewish cultures. Students discussed, wrote, identified the setting, main characters, problem, and solution. After also discovering the central message and the moral of a story, students participated in an online game and completed summative and formative assessments. Integrating multicultural children’s books creates a sense of belonging and helps to create community.
Download Unit: Miller-D.pdf
Did you try this unit in your classroom? Give us your feedback here.
I am a white woman. I’ve had privileges and built in advantages. I have not been profiled nor stereotyped. I can walk into a store and not be singled out. But that doesn’t mean I don’t have biases. One bias I have is that I would cross the street if I saw a group of young black men. (Honestly, I have worked to overcome this bias). Another bias also showed up in the texts I selected for my students. For over thirty three years, I’ve selected picture books for my classroom based on the content, the illustrations, and if the story won a Newbery Award for the storyline or Caldecott Award for the pictures. Illustrations are very important in picture books because young students look to the pictures for the meaning of the text. If I liked the message or the accompanying pretty pictures, I figured it would be a good fit for my students, even though it didn’t represent the diversity in my classroom. Because I was not enlightened, I did a disservice to all races of children in my classroom. My students did not see themselves in the texts I selected. They did not see themselves reflected back, like a mirror. They probably only saw white characters… What kind of biases would that create with my pupils?! Biases that I now know can be dispelled for me and my students through quality authentic children’s literature. In other words and for example, a book written by an Asian author has Asian characters. This would make the Asian book more authentic. The purpose of my “Culturally Authentic Picture Books: How To Dispel the Single Story” unit is for students to hear and see picture books that are about a certain culture written by a person of that same culture – a more accurate and authentic approach to writing because the author has experienced the subject matter first hand (Brooks, 2025). Authentic Picture Books depict realistic stories and illustrations that reflect current ideology, customs, and everyday life ( Wee, 2014). They have culturally accurate text and illustrations. They comprise not only the absence of stereotypes but also the presence of values consistent with a particular culture and the accuracy of cultural details in text and illustrations (Yoo-Lee, Fowler, Adkins, Kim, and Davis 2014). Students may have encountered different cultures. Some may have even misinterpreted that specific culture, have a single story, have had only one experience with that culture, and/or seen negative images of a culture in the media and created a single story about a specific culture which could be negative (Brooks, 2025). I want to dismiss the belief that one story represents and defines an entire culture. Therefore, I will use two Picture Books to study each of the three cultures in my unit curriculum . My unit seeks to dispel the single story and present accurate information about a particular culture in multiple picture books – authenticity. I now need to be highly selective and intentional in the Picture Books I select for my class. My first goal is for all of my current second graders to see themselves in the Picture Books we read, like a mirror. My second goal is to dispel the Single Story – only hearing one thing about a particular culture that can be positive or negative. My third goal is to give my students the opportunity to understand others of diverse backgrounds and create a deeper understanding of cultural values (Wee, 2014). This unit will help students to develop a positive appreciation for other groups of people as well as to hear authentic or accurate portrals of specific cultures. These picture books will be informative for my students because they will be exposed to cultures other than their own, like a window where they can see into another culture, and they can identify with the characters, like a mirror reflecting back their own image or culture. The illustrations are just as important as the text in picture books because the students can see the culture for themselves. The illustrations and the text will work together for the reader. By reading literary texts, students will acquire the necessary skills to learn how to respect, accept, and appreciate diversity as something positive for the collective development of the group.” (Tomé-Fernández, Senís-Fernández, Ruiz-Martín, 2019) Authentic picturebooks act not only as a mirror in which students are reflected but also as a window through which they can see other cultural experiences especially because text and images are intertwined in picture books (Tomé-Fernández, Senís-Fernández, Ruiz-Martín, 2019). Children put a lot of emphasis on the pictures to help comprehend the text. For every child in my class, I want them to be able to see themselves in our literature – mirrors to see themselves and create a feeling of importance. The books for this curriculum unit are representative of my current students. My search for culturally diverse literature began with looking at the cultures in my own classroom. We are African American, White, Muslim, Jewish, and Protestant/Catholic. Yet, not every child in my class is familiar with other cultures of their fellow students. In particular, the students in my class know about the dominant White culture and Protestant/Catholic religion (from holidays), therefore, I decided not to read a book about White culture or Protestant/Catholic beliefs. They can view other cultures through read alouds to look through windows to view other societies and ways of life (Brooks 2025). My students can look through a window to see other cultures represented in our classroom, as well as see themselves in the Picture Books like looking in a mirror. Reading intercultural books “…allows students to empathize with the characters presented in those books. It also allows them to indirectly explore their thoughts and emotions, develop important ideas, and increase awareness, knowledge, understanding, and acceptance of oneself and others” (Tomé-Fernández, Senís-Fernández, Ruiz-Martín, pages 205 – 213, 2019). Isn’t that a big goal of education? Thanks to the work of Dr. Wanda Brooks, I am becoming more well-informed and awakened to give children a genuine look at the kaleidoscope of races and cultures through authentic texts. I want to teach the multitude of different races and cultures in my class by utilizing Picture Books to create mirrors, windows, and dispel the single story. My goal is to create a curriculum that contains numerous authentic resources for teachers to build into their own curriculum and use in their classrooms.
To design effective instruction I will need to focus on multiple areas: including student engagement or how well students participate, active learning or the extent students participate in the learning, collaborative learning or working together in teams, assessment or grading students, and differentiation or adjusting a student’s work to make it easier or more difficult for the student to experience success. Student engagement or commitment is key. If students aren’t interested in what I am teaching, they will not participate nor learn or internalize anything. I want to spark my students’ curiosities and have them wonder ‘Why?’ I hope my students will literally be leaning forward in their seats with interest! Because I will present multicultural learning, my lessons will have clear and authentic real-world connections right to my students. I planned my lessons with the cultural make-up of my students in the forefront of my mind. I desire for my students to be seen in our Picture Books (like in the reflection of a mirror) and to learn about other cultures (like in a window to other things). Class discussions, or talking about the topic, are an integral part of my unit, varying from partner talk with two students, to small groups with a few students, to whole class discussions. Active learning is creating, making connections, and building upon prior knowledge. This requires students to be creative and use critical thinking. Students are not to be passive (and just sit there) but are to be innovative and deliberate when creating a project. I strive to have my students use kinesthetic skills or tactile abilities to develop and design a culminating or final project to demonstrate their learning. Using kinesthetic skills will help to keep my students engaged and excited. Active learning will occur when the students create their own family shield and also during the online learning game Blooket. Collaborative learning or working and communicating together creates a community of learners. Collaborative learning will happen in small groups that work to respond to the Picture Books as Read Alouds. This is vital because it brings students together in a joint venture, whether creating, understanding, or accruing meaning. Students are more likely to take an active role in peer-peer learning in order to learn from each other when working cooperatively. During our classroom discussions, students can absorb and discuss what other students are thinking and expressing about their own ideas. Different perspectives will arise and challenge students to think critically about the others’ positions. Students will also learn to agree or disagree respectfully. Building a strong sense of community is important for students to learn and take into adulthood. Assessment enables teachers to differentiate and design personalized learning for students while collecting data. Teachers can monitor students and stylize instruction to meet student needs. Formative, or ongoing, assessments can range from participation, to written and technological work, to test scores and become an ongoing process. The purpose of formative assessments is to guide students to mastery of the current content with a final project or even a test. Summative assessment occurs at the end of a unit, chapter, or term. It evaluates what a student has learned and how much they understand. I will incorporate narrative and opinion writings and creating a family shield as summative assessments. Differentiation is meeting a child where they are academically, and designing instruction to help them grow to mastery. This is vital because every classroom has students with different needs and ability levels. Differentiation recognizes and embraces differences in learning needs and abilities, as well as increases motivation and achievement. I will also use differentiation when we break up into teacher led groups to discuss a picture book. During writing assessments, I will meet with groups of students to help with a needed writing skill, such as grammar, phonics (letters to their sounds), organization, or content (what they wrote).
Materials: Lesson Plan for “One Classroom, Many Cultures”. Background: As a whole group, ask the students to share out about their own cultures and traditions. After a few students have shared, the teacher shares about their own culture. Explain the specific purpose of this unit – To read culturally authentic picture books about different cultures in order to become familiar with the different races and cultures in the classroom. Culturally authentic means the author is of the same culture as the characters in the picture book. But it could also mean an authentic book written by an outsider, as long as their writing is accurate. I prefer culturally authentic to be written by an author who is of the same race or ethnicity as the story. I feel the stories will be more realistic. Instruction: 2.Students will be able to (SWBAT) discover how African Americans get their haircut and/or braided in order to (IOT) learn about African American culture. Materials: Lesson Plan for “Crown: An Ode To The Fresh Cut” and “Hair Love”: Background: Ask the students what it’s like when they get a haircut or hair braiding. Tell the students to ‘turn and talk’ to their partner to compare experiences. Bring the students back to whole group and ask for volunteers to share out their hair experiences. Ask the whole group if there ever was a time when they felt ‘on top of the world’ after your hair has been worked on, like you could do anything. Instruction: Materials: Lesson Plan for “The Proudest Blue” and “Juha, The Funny and Wise Muslim Storyteller”. Folktales and Fables are part of the district’s curriculum, therefore, I included this in my curriculum unit. Background: Ask the students if they have ever seen a head scarf on a woman or a girl? Why do you think they would wear this? If there is a Muslim girl in the class, ask her if she wishes to share out about her headscarf. Gather information about how many students are familiar with the Muslim culture by asking, “What do you know about the Muslim culture?” Call on a few students to share out their experiences. Instruction: 4.SWBAT discover what a Yidish Folktale is and learn about Jewish art and Judaica (objects that hold significance in Jewish history or Jewish culture)artifacts IOT gain an appreciation for the Jewish culture and religion. Materials: “Olive Loves Being Jewish” by Natalie goldman “It Could Always Be Worse’ by Margot Zemach – Caldecott Honor Book A shield pattern on paper Lesson Plan for “Olive Loves Being Jewish” and “It Could Always Be Worse”. Folktales and Fables are part of the district’s curriculum, therefore, I included this in my curriculum unit.
Activity Sheets Story Elements and Central Message: file:///C:/Users/dkami/OneDrive/Desktop/250418%20DKM%20SCAN%201%20PDF.pdf Family Shield: file:///C:/Users/dkami/OneDrive/Desktop/250418%20DKM%20SCAN%202%20PDF.pdf Abby. (2017). Crown: An ode to the fresh cut. Crown: An Ode to the Fresh Cut. https://www.abbythelibrarian.com/2017/11/crown-ode-to-fresh-cut.html Aronson, Krista Maywalt, et al. “Messages matter: Investigating the thematic content of picture books portraying underrepresented racial and cultural groups.” Sociological Forum, vol. 33, no. 1, 29 (Dec. 2017), pp. 165–185, https://doi.org/10.1111/socf.12404. Brooks, W. (2025). T.I.P. Cherry, Matthew. “The Story behind ‘Hair Love.’” The Story Behind Hair Love, 2019, sffilm.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/SFFILM_EDU_StudyGuide_Hair-Love.pdf . Mendoza, J. (2001). Examining Multicultural Picture Books for the Early Childhood Classroom: Possibilities and Pitfalls. Early Childhood Research & Practice, 3(2). Roethler, Jacque. “Reading in color: Children’s book illustrations and Identity Formation for black children in the United States.” African American Review, vol. 32, no. 1, 1998, p. 95, https://doi.org/10.2307/3042272. Stephens , D., & Darri Stephens Darri Stephens is a dedicated LX (learning experience) designer. (2025, March 13). 7 essential strategies for designing effective instruction. Nearpod Blog. https://nearpod.com/blog/effective-instruction/, Su-Jeong Wee, Kanae Kura, & Sohyun Meacham. “Half and Half: Racial Identity Development of Multiracial Asian American Children Portrayed in Children’s Picture Books.” Journal of Children’s Literature, Vol. 47, Iss. 1, (Spring 2021): 21-35. “Ted Talks: Chimamanda Adichie–the Danger of a Single Story.” TED, 2009. (http://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story?language=en) Tomé‐Fernández, M., Senís‐Fernández, J., & Ruiz‐Martín, D. (2019). Values and intercultural experiences through picture books. The Reading Teacher, 73(2), 205–213. https://doi.org/10.1002/trtr.1813 Wee, Su-Jeong, et al. “Korean culture as portrayed in young children’s picture books: The pursuit of cultural authenticity.” Children’s Literature in Education, vol. 46, no. 1, 15 June 2014, pp. 70–87, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10583-014-9224-0. Yoo-Lee, E., Fowler, L., Adkins, D., Kim, K.-S., & Davis, H. N. (2014). Evaluating cultural authenticity in multicultural picture books: A collaborative analysis for diversity education. The Library Quarterly, 84(3), 324–347. https://doi.org/10.1086/676490 Additional authentic multicultural texts:
Pennsylvania State Standards Standard – CC.1.2.2.A Identify the main idea of a multi-paragraph text as well as the focus of specific paragraphs within the text. Standard – CC.1.2.2.B Ask and answer questions such as who, what, where, when, why, and how to demonstrate understanding of key details in a text. Standard – CC.1.2.2.C Describe the connection between a series of events, concepts, or steps in a procedure within a text. Standard – CC.1.2.2.H Describe how reasons support specific points the author makes in a text. Standard – CC.1.2.2.I Compare and contrast the most important points presented by two texts on the same topic. Standard – CC.1.2.2.J Acquire and use grade-appropriate conversational, general academic, and domain-specific words and phrases. Standard – CC.1.3.2.A Recount stories and determine their central message, lesson, or moral. Standard – CC.1.3.2.B Ask and answer questions such as who, what, where, when, why, and how to demonstrate understanding of key details in a text. Standard – CC.1.3.2.C Describe how characters in a story respond to major events and challenges. Standard – CC.1.3.2.E Describe the overall structure of a story, including describing how the beginning introduces the story and the ending concludes the action. Standard – CC.1.3.2.F Describe how words and phrases supply rhythm and meaning in a story, poem, or song. Standard – CC.1.3.2.G Use information from illustrations and words, in print or digital text, to demonstrate understanding of characters, setting, or plot. Standard – CC.1.3.2.J Acquire and use grade-appropriate conversational, general academic, and domain-specific words and phrases. Standard – CC.1.4.2.A Write informative/ explanatory texts to examine a topic and convey ideas and information clearly. Standard – CC.1.4.2.F Demonstrate a grade-appropriate command of the conventions of standard English grammar, usage, capitalization, punctuation, and spelling. • Capitalize proper nouns. • Use commas and apostrophes appropriately. • Spell words drawing on common spelling patterns. • Consult reference material as needed Standard – CC.1.4.2.G Write opinion pieces on familiar topics or texts. Standard – CC.1.4.2.H Identify the topic and state an opinion. Standard – CC.1.4.2.J Create an organizational structure that includes reasons and includes a concluding statement. Standard – CC.1.4.2.L Demonstrate a grade-appropriate command of the conventions of standard English grammar, usage, capitalization, punctuation, and spelling. • Capitalize proper nouns. • Use commas and apostrophes appropriately. • Spell words drawing on common spelling patterns. • Consult reference material as needed. Standard – CC.1.4.2.M Write narratives to develop real or imagined experiences or events. Standard – CC.1.4.2.N Establish a situation and introduce a narrator and/or characters. Standard – CC.1.4.2.O Include thoughts and feelings to describe experiences and events to show the response of characters to situations. Standard – CC.1.4.2.P Organize a short sequence of events, using temporal words to signal event order; provide a sense of closure. Standard – CC.1.4.2.Q Choose words and phrases for effect Standard – CC.1.4.2.T With guidance and support from adults and peers, focus on a topic and strengthen writing as needed by revising and editing. Standard – CC.1.5.2.A Participate in collaborative conversations with peers and adults in small and larger groups. Standard – CC.1.5.2.B Recount or describe key ideas or details from a text read aloud or information presented orally or through other media. Standard – 8.4.2.A Explain why cultures have commemorations and remembrances. handouts, evaluation rubrics, etc.