Author: Shaquita Smith
School/Organization:
Office of Curriculum and Instruction, School District of Philadelphia
Year: 2024
Seminar: Asian Meditation Traditions Past and Present
Grade Level: 6-8
Keywords: Bhavana, Buddha, community, compassion, dharma, empathy, equanimity, Meditation, meta (Metacognitive thinking) meditation, sangha, Three Jewels
School Subject(s): Social Studies
This unit will focus on social justice through the lens of using Asian Meditative Practices to assist with developing and nurturing community and social emotional support for students. Meditation can and has helped students globally and nationally become more thoughtful people as well as agents in managing their own behaviors. Meditation has been reported to be a great emotional self-regulating practice. The practice of meditation develops in one a sense of belonging to a community that not only holds one accountable also supports and assists with the social emotional growth of its members. This unit is intended for social studies teachers in grades 6-8. However, it can be used in all content areas and grade levels. In this unit, students will also work to improve their critical analysis and evaluation skills through the interviews, reading and analysis of research, op-ed articles, and video recordings on the benefits of meditation and community. Learners will improve their speaking and listening skills through practicing meditation techniques, interviews, collaborative practices such as writing, discussion and active listening while critically analyzing text and conversations. Students will also practice their reflective writing skills throughout this unit. Finally, this unit also supports educators with building and nurturing collaborative communities in their classroom.
Download Unit: Smith-S-Unit.pdf
Did you try this unit in your classroom? Give us your feedback here.
Initially, I was excited and had apprehension about taking a course on meditation. The idea of taking a course on meditation was exciting because I wanted to learn more about the practices I personally had been engaging in for years and its history. Prior to the course, most of what I learned about meditation and mindfulness came from podcasts, Youtube videos, meditation apps and from people in the entertainment world like Depak Chopra. This UPenn TIP course did not disappoint. Through the TIP course our class was able to learn about multiple mediation histories and traditions from Asia, including India and China. There are several different types of meditation found in Indian and Chinese cultures. We studied Buddhism, Jainism, Metta meditation, yoga sutra and more. Each class consisted of learning about the histories of an Asian meditation tradition and then practicing a form of meditation. We started with breathing and focusing and eventually moved into Metta meditation. This course also introduced us to a number of practitioners and researchers of meditation including Halvor Eifring’s compendium of research on Asian meditation traditions. Our class read and discussed the epic Bhagavad-Gita and the Yoga Sutras to understand how meditation helps us with being good, compassionate, empathetic and supportive members of our community and doing what is right. Through the course discussions, readings, practices and speakers, I was able to gain understanding about the purpose, benefits and disadvantages of meditation. I learned meditation can be found in many forms, in all world religions and in a multitude of cultural practices. My apprehension about the course was rooted in how I was going to create an instructional unit for teachers to implement in their classrooms when they already have a full load of content to teach. It was extremely necessary to not retraumatize students through the quiet exploration of the inner self that happens with meditation. However, learning about the various meditative traditions eventually revealed the main focus of meditation is community, or the Sangha. Community is an integral part of the classroom. Therefore, I decided the focus of the instructional unit will be on developing community in the classroom through meditative practices. The contents of this unit will mostly cover Asian Mediation traditions. Although students will have the opportunity to learn about other meditation or mindfulness traditions found in other cultures, specifically those from various Native American cultures and cultures from Africa, they will predominantly apply and practice the components of Asian Meditation traditions. The unit helps teachers and students explore building and nurturing collaborative classroom communities through the use of and understanding Meta, Yoga Sutras, Buddhist meditation practices. This unit will guide students to critically think about what community is as well as explore how their actions support or hinder community development and growth. This unit will also seek to assist students with exploring the benefits of meditation to improve their overall wellbeing, personal social emotional growth, and calming anxiety. However, it is important to reiterate here, the goal is to improve their classroom community versus focusing on “fixing the student,” one of the core beliefs of culturally responsive and relative teaching. Because the focus is on improving the community classroom, metta meditation and the Yoga Sutras was chosen as the focus practice. The hope is that upon completion of the unit teachers and students will continue the practices of meditation introduced, continue to nurture their community or seek other practices as well as guide others in their communities and families towards meditation. Implementation of the unit will take students on a journey of learning experiences to help them understand the value and impact of meditation on our lives in community and education. The class will start their journey by defining community and its importance through interviews of adults and peers. Then they will develop, as a whole class, a “checklist” of criteria for defining the characteristics for community and finally compare and edit that criteria “checklist” with information gathered through interviews, class discussions, readings and other resources provided by researchers and culture groups who practice community. Next students will evaluate or reflect on their school community based on the criteria they have previously created. Students will then gain an understanding of what meditation is through video analysis, readings, discussions and other resources about different meditation traditions and practice some of those traditions. After gaining some understanding of what meditation is, students will then explore the benefits of meditation, its connections to nurturing community and how non-western schools and schools in the United State use meditative practices. Students will then explore how meditation helps the individual students and the school community. Then students will briefly learn about a particular meditative tradition and practice it. Finally, students will privately reflect on what they are feeling emotionally and physically as well as how they feel about whether the meditation motivates their desire to nurture community in their classroom before and after they implement the meditation technique. Due to this unit focusing on community building, it is intended to be implemented in the first few weeks of school. The earlier the implementation during the school year, the more likely the community will develop and flourish. Students will conduct inquiry on the following essential questions:
For this unit I wanted teachers to have strategies that build empathy, critical thinking and analysis skills, community and deepen students’ understanding of content. These skills are transferable and relevant in any content area as well as the world outside their physical classrooms. Therefore I chose interviews, thoughtful question formulation, collaborative classroom practices, gallery walks, meditation practices, reflection. Question Formulation Technique Asking the right question is a technique that is critically foundational to literacy. Students’ abilities to grow and thrive as learners and continued learners are grounded in their ability to ask the right questions to gain new understandings, perform inquiries and synthesize knowledge. Asking the right questions also helps students build empathy and self-advocacy skills. The Question Formulation Technique is a process that supports students in their skills of developing questions. Through QFT students write questions and improve those questions through the processes of categorization and iteration. With QFT, students are encouraged to write and ask open-ended questions that will open the door for new and extension of learning. Collaborative Classroom Practices/Discussions Collaborative classroom practices are vital to helping students develop deeper understanding of concepts and processes and build empathy, community and critical thinking. All of which will help students fulfill the purpose of learning which is to be able to critically examine the world in which they live and beyond. Collaborative learning is a deeper practice of learning than cooperative learning in which students learn to be dependent as well as interdependent. By the completion of this unit students will have worked with the same group four of students with various perspectives and the whole class interdependently. Students will have shared knowledge and authority in various iterations as a practice throughout the entire unit. Silent Discussion A silent discussion is a great technique to help all students, especially quiet or shy students, share their voice and promote critical thinking skills. This technique can be used as a scaffold to the Think, Pair, and Sharing technique. The process for silent discussion is simple. First, students are given a question, document to read, or an image to analyze. Students then write their thoughts or questions either on chart paper or an electronic version of a group chat (e.g. jamboard, Padlet, etc.). Their thoughts and conclusions must be shared in a public yet semi-anonymous way in order for other students to respond by extending the thought or adding a question to extend the thought. The teacher then provides students time to observe the thoughts and questions of their peers. After students have had to observe the thoughts and questions of their peers, they are to respond in writing to at least two to three other student’s comments or questions. Their response must be thoughtful by extending the conversation through comment or question. This previous step can be repeated or the teacher can have students repeat it after a whole class or small group discussion. Whether the previous step is repeated at the end, students are to discuss the comments and questions that they find the most compelling, resonate with them, or encourage them to ask more questions in small groups or as a whole class discussion. Their goals of this discussion are to either deepen their understanding, synthesize knowledge and possibly develop new inquiry questions. Actively Listening In order for students to have discussions in classrooms that will be impactful to their learning they must practice active listening. Active listening allows students to hear what their peers are really saying by requiring that a person concentrate on listening for what is said rather than listening to respond. This practice requires paraphrasing, questioning and evaluation of the conversation. Active listening builds empathy and community in the classroom. Active listening also improves students’ discourse and critical analysis and thinking skills. Gallery Walks Gallery Walks are a great way to help students share knowledge, deepen their understanding of content and processes, build community and active listening skills and have discussions. Gallery walks are suggested in several of the activities in this unit to also help students develop interdependency and provide equity for quiet or shy students or those who might have apprehension about sharing their thoughts with opportunities to be actively engaged in ways that are more comforting for them. It allows the teacher to act as mediator, meet students where they are as well as have full class engagement. Jigsaw The Jigsaw strategy supports teachers in facilitating learning with large complex concepts or processes. This strategy also aids students to become “experts” with particular pieces of content as they share their learning and gain new knowledge through the collaborative practice of sharing knowledge. With the Jigsaw students are also able to develop their collaboration and discussion skills. Finally, this strategy also encourages practicing equity in the classroom since it allows the teacher to chunk and scaffold the learning for all students, especially for students who may have challenges with reading and writing. Metacognitive practices Metacognitive teaching strategies assist in developing deeper understanding of learning and how one learns. Metacognitive practices are essential aid in developing students’ independent and interdependent learning skills through getting the student to think about and evaluate their thinking and learning to find pathways to become better learners. It is a key practice in iteration.
Lesson 1: Community Criteria – How do I and my class define community Guiding Questions Objective: Students will analyze definitions and text to assist with defining a community in order to create a list of criteria for community. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression Lesson 2: How do others around me define Community? Guiding Questions: Objective: Students will analyze definitions and text to assist with defining a community in order to create a list of criteria for community. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression Lesson 3: Text and Video Analysis of research on Community Guiding Questions Objective: Students will analyze multiple sources in order to continue developing understandings about community. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression: Lesson 4: Evaluating Our Community Guiding Questions Objective: Students will be able to synthesize knowledge about what community is and why it is important to evaluate their classroom community. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression: Lesson 5: Understanding Meditation and Mindfulness and the Benefits Guiding Questions Objective: Students will explore various meditation traditions in order to define meditation and understand why one practice might be more helpful to them versus another. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression: Lesson 6: Nurturing Community Guiding Questions: Objective: The students will define compassion, empathy, and equanimity in order to understand how important such character traits are to building and nurturing community. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression: Lesson 7: Practicing Meditation and Reflection Guiding Questions: Objective: Students will explore various meditative practices in order to describe how the benefits of meditation can help nurture community. Standards: Pennsylvania Career Readiness Skills Continuum Learning Experience Progression:
60 Minutes. (2020). Brené Brown: The secret to having compassion. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCvhOqThYJ4. Bears, C. (2019). Classic Care Bears | Care Bear Stare (and Cousins Call) Mega Compilation! On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYKc-WiKuNI Benefits of Mindfulness Meditation. (2020, June 8). Harmony Family Yoga | Modern Yoga Studio. https://harmonyfamilyyoga.com/benefits-of-mindfulness-meditation/. Brown, B. (2016). Brené Brown on Empathy vs Sympathy [YouTube Video]. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KZBTYViDPlQ. Buddhism. (2022). Guided Loving Kindness Meditation… | Buddhism In English. In YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDi40FQcaIU. Buddhism. (2023, October 14). How To Meditate In A Busy Life | Buddhism In English. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXXhSWMqeD8. Chen, T. (1999). The Fundamentals of Meditation Practice www.buddhanet.net Buddha Dharma Education Association Inc. (pp. 11–14). https://www.buddhanet.net/pdf_file/chanmed1.pdf. Clinton, M. (2017, August 21). 9 Fascinating Proverbs to Help You Understand an African Worldview. International Mission Board; International Mission Board. https://www.imb.org/2017/08/21/9-fascinating-proverbs-to-help-you-understand-an-african-worldview/. Cult of Pedagogy. (2015). The Jigsaw Method. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=euhtXUgBEts. This video is only for instructional purposes for the teacher. Dawson, V. (2021, November 7). All Our Relations: Four Indigenous Lessons on Mindfulness. Mindful. https://www.mindful.org/all-our-relations-four-indigenous-lessons-on-mindfulness/. Driver, M. (2018, June 19). What are the Yoga Sutras? Asheville Yoga Center. https://youryoga.com/what-are-the-yoga-sutras/#:~:text=In%20a%20nutshell%2C%20the%20Yoga. Ford, S. (2021, June 16). Yoga and Buddhist Philosophy: The Brahmaviharas and Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra 1.33. Integral Yoga San Francisco. https://integralyogasf.org/yoga-and-buddhist-philosophy-the-brahmaviharas-and-patanjalis-yoga-sutra-1-33/. Forman, C. (2016, January 11). The Native American Code of Ethics. Www.thewayofmeditation.com.au. https://www.thewayofmeditation.com.au/the-native-american-code-of-ethics. Gallery Walk – The Teacher Toolkit. (n.d.). Www.theteachertoolkit.com. https://www.theteachertoolkit.com/index.php/tool/gallery-walk. Hanh, T. N. (1976). The Miracle of Mindfulness (pp. 3–8). https://terebess.hu/zen/mesterek/Thich%20Nhat%20Hanh%20-%20The%20Miracle%20of%20Mindfulness.pdf. Infographic: Meditation in Schools Across America. (2012, February 22). Edutopia. https://www.edutopia.org/stw-student-stress-meditation-schools-infographic. Introduction To Breathing Meditation | Buddhism In English. (2023, June). Www.youtube.com. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-dHOWvFZa4M. Marie, M. (2017, September 5). Native American Traditions in Meditation. Medium. https://medium.com/@msealymindfulleadership/how-to-meditate-using-native-american-traditions-230c2b1bcc26. Meditation | Psychology Today. (2019). Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/meditation. Mobe, T. (2022, May 23). 8 African Proverbs That Every Global Citizen Should Know. Global Citizen. https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/africa-proverbs-global-citizens-action-end-poverty/. Psychology Today. (2019). Mindfulness | Psychology Today. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/mindfulness. Sense Of Community explained. (2016). [YouTube Video]. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ey4wsa4_fZg. Spiritual Friendship Is the Path. (2021). Lion’s Roar. https://www.lionsroar.com/spiritual-friendship-is-the-path/. Stinson, K. (2024, April 16). MGH Guides: Study Breaks: Mindfulness for Healthcare Providers. Libguides.massgeneral.org. https://libguides.massgeneral.org/studybreaks/mindfulness. Study Buddhism. (2018). What is Equanimity? | Dr Chönyi Taylor. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PX8CY-1eOM0. The Sanskrit Channel. (2020, January 7). Learn BhagavadGita with Narration of Meanings – Chapter 6. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sb4UsflFpJ8. The Sanskrit Channel. (2021, June 9). Detailed Patanjali Yoga Sutras with Pictures – Chapter 1 – States of Meditativeness. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L1jdEWSEFUo. The Triple Gem – Intro into Buddhism. (2023, December). Www.youtube.com. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0c0K0Pvmg4. Ting, M. (2020). Sense of Community. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYcmg33ydGw. Vasundhara Talware. (2021, May 18). Yoga Sutra 1.33: Four Love Languages of Yoga. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7P0b54i6OkQ. Washington State Library. (2021). CHIEF SEATTLE’S LETTER. Csun.edu. https://www.csun.edu/~vcpsy00h/seattle.htm. Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche. (2011). A Guided Meditation on the Body, Space, and Awareness with Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche. On YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GSeWdjyr1c. Youth Focus. (n.d.). “I have coloured in the MINDFUL COLOURING. https://youthfocus.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/YF_Mindful-Colouring_FA.pdf. Zephyrion. (2023, March 29). The Benefits and Challenges of Practicing Mindfulness Meditation. Medium. https://medium.com/@vaqarali387/the-benefits-and-challenges-of-practicing-mindfulness-meditation-7c433f1eb405.