Overview
Images stay with you in your memory for a long time. Some images never leave your mind. Americans have seen images of war come and go and they have seen images of war in movies as well as photographs. Some are disturbing and some are inspirational. Through art and photography, Americans are able to connect with what soldiers’ experience. Through images, the people at home or students sitting in a classroom can experience the glories of patriotism as well as the horrors of war through images. Whether the images are portrayed in movies, still photographs or poems, art has a way of allowing a person to connect on a deeper level.
This unit will provide an overview of images from several American wars. The unit will also discuss how the American people perceive and connect to the image of a warrior or war hero. This unit will study the images including paintings, posters, or photography from the Revolutionary War, the Civil War, WWI, WWII, and the Vietnam War.
Rationale and Historical Context
Students from various grade levels in the School District of Philadelphia study American history. 8th grade students in particular study the time period from the first explorers of the new world to the modern time period. There is a vast amount of material to cover and a collection of images from U.S. History giving the students a brief overview of several wars that America has fought in will help students connect with history and help them to understand what our country has been through as well. Images of a battlefield of fallen soldiers can show the horrors of war while patriotic images of soldiers raising a flag can inspire. Students must study all of the American wars, but there are very few images and photographs in textbooks for students to see. This unit will allow for this exploration.
When a country is at war this will have an effect on the subject matter chosen by artists. Artists are considered “as sufferer and faithful reporter of horrors, as having undergone a change of personality…and his views on art and its function altered forever” (Lambourne, 1999, p. 348-9). Often art produced during wars might show war damage as a subject, “showing sad scenes of ruined churches” (p. 349). Also, it might have been assumed that art would be destroyed during war times, but actually this is not the case—instead there was a lot of art constructed, produced, and used for propaganda (p. 351). Sometimes precise figures of the death toll were not available so images of bombarded cathedrals and damaged statues acted as descriptions of the destruction of war (p. 356).
Through media and technology, teachers are able to access a wide array of images for students to view. Sometimes long chapters of text can be cumbersome while an image, photograph, or a poster will allow students to learn just as well (Allen, 1994, p. 52). Posters combine visual images with short messages for display in public places. Color posters originally were used in 1838 in England and when studied provide a “vivid and powerful presentation of a message” (Allen, p. 52). The posters from the past show a record of ideas, products, concerns and events and through studying them students will be able to better understand the events in history. Posters were used as means of recruiting during the war or as a way to help people back home remember what was taking place overseas. They also served other purposes, and the government would use them to send important messages to people as well as to encourage people to take action.
Posters not only “functioned as illustrations of the war in popular understanding but also had an impact on the facts of the war, including its duration and its reach” (James, 2009, 3). Though we can appreciate the images from many of the posters from earlier wars, often times it is challenging to understand their scope and importance to the generations who viewed them (p. 3). During World War One, also called “the poster war,” posters became the favored propaganda tool (p. 5).
Posters were accepted and understood by the public; they were tried and tested and cheap (p. 5). Most read posters for their images—the image is “what appears in a picture, and what survives its destruction—in memory, in narrative, and in copies and traces in other media” (p. 8). Posters came in many sizes and they also were displayed in parades, rallies, and exhibits. The posters were displayed in shop windows, banks schools, churches, libraries, town halls, factories, recruiting stations, offices, and homes, as well is in cities, small towns and rural areas (p. 10). Also, if the image on the poster was a popular one, it was reissued, but perhaps in a different color or with a different quotation (p. 11).
Posters needed to appeal quickly to a viewer and it must be able to be understood by people who are on the move. The message of a poster cannot be too complex for this sort of viewing—they should be “single, clear, specific” and “must appeal to the emotions rather than to the intellect” (p. 20). Posters were successful at “blurring the lines between fact and fantasy” and also at the same time kept people from having to deal with the war’s “hardest truths—the killing and death at its center” (p. 32). Posters did not show the war’s human costs.
Images of Wars and Warriors
In this section of the curriculum unit I will be showing several images of wars from American History. Throughout this section there are also some suggestions of literature for students to read to coincide with their study of posters, images and photos.
Revolutionary War
The following links provide many images of the Revolutionary War. http://www.archives.gov/research/american-revolution/pictures/
http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/revolution-images/
http://ushistoryimages.com/revolutionary-war.shtm
Revolutionary War Reading List for middle school students:
Poems/Novels
Paul Revere’s Ride by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (Elements of Literature, 8th grade text book).
Barbara Frietchie by John Greenleaf Whittier
My Brother Sam is Dead by James Lincoln Collier
Sarah Bishop by Scott O’Dell
The Fifth of March: a Story of the Boston Massacre by Ann Rinaldi
Toliver’s Secret by Esther Brady
The Fighting Ground by Avi
Johnny Tremain by Esther Forbes
Civil War
The following links provide many images of the Civil War.
http://www.archives.gov/research/civil-war/photos/
http://www.treasurenet.com/images/
http://americancivilwar.com/pictures/
http://sunsite.utk.edu/civil-war/
http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/cwphtml/tl1861.html
http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/cwphtml/cwphome.html
http://www.pbs.org/civilwar/images/
http://www.civilwarphotos.net/
http://www.civilwar-pictures.com/
http://www.civil-war.net/
Civil War Reading List for middle school students:
Short Stories/Novels
The Drummer Boy at Shiloh, Elements of Literature (8th grade text book). This story explains the courage of a boy from who is about to experience his first major battle—the Battle of Shiloh, where there were almost 24,000 casualties.
The Deserter, Elements of Literature (8th grade text book). This story is an except from Across Five Aprils by Irene Hunt and talks about the experiences of a deserter from the Union Army.
The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane
Across Five Aprils by Irene Hunt
Undying Glory: The Story of the Massachusetts 54th Regiment by Clinton Cox
To Be a Slave by Julius Lester
Stonewall by Jean Fritz
Across the Lines by Carolyn Reeder
Soldier’s Heart by Gary Paulsen
WWI
Below are several excellent sites with images of the Great War.
http://www.firstworldwar.com/index.htm
http://www.gwpda.org/photos/coppermine/index.php
http://www.world-war-pictures.com/american-war-posters.htm
http://www.world-war-pictures.com/american-world-war-photos.htm
http://www.worldwaronecolorphotos.com/
http://history1900s.about.com/library/photos/blyindexwwi.htm
WWI Reading List for middle school students:
When Christmas Comes Again by Beth Seidel Levine
His Banner Over Me by Jean Little
Goodbye Billy Radish by Jean Little
Tree by Leaf by Cynthia Voight
WWII
The links below provide many photos of World War II.
http://www.archives.gov/research/ww2/photos/
http://www.acepilots.com/ww2/pictures.html
http://www.ww2incolor.com/
http://www.historyplace.com/unitedstates/pacificwar/index.html
http://www.teacheroz.com/WWIIpropaganda.htm
http://www.world-war-pictures.com/
http://www.historylink101.com/ww2_color/index.html
The following website contains posters from WWII http://www.acepilots.com/ww2/home.html
WWII Reading List for middle school students:
Alex, Who Won His War by Chester Aaron
The Light in the Cellar by Sarah Buckey
A Spy on the Homefront by Alison Hart
Two Suns in the Sky by Miriam Bat-Ami
My Friend the Enemy by J.B. Cheaney
Camp Harmony from Nisei Daughter by Monica Sone (Elements of Literature, 8th grade text book)
Early Sunday Morning by Barry Deneberg
The Journal of Ben Uchida by Barry Deneberg
Lily’s Crossing by Patricial Reilly Giff
Under the Blood-Red Sun by Graham Salisbury
The Moon Bridge by Marcia Savin
Heroes Don’t Run by Harry Mazer
Diary of Anne Frank (Play is in the Elements of Literature book, 8th grade text book)
Vietnam War
Below are several links to images from the Vietnam War.
http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/vietnam-photos/
http://history1900s.about.com/od/vietnamwar/tp/vietnamwarpictures.htm
http://www.vietnampix.com/index.html
http://www.patriotduty.com/
http://vietnamphotography.com/
http://militaryhistory.about.com/od/vietnamwar/ig/Vietnam-War-Images/
Vietnam War Reading List for middle school students:
Lost in the War by Nancy Antie
The Best of Friends by Margaret Rostkowski
The Journal of Patrick Seamus Flaherty, United States Marine Corps by Ellen Emerson White
The Image of the Warrior throughout American History
America has been involved in many wars on numerous fronts and throughout the warriors have been honored, imitated and perceived with awe throughout American history (Linenthal, p. 4). America’s founding fathers were connected with war—the Revolutionary War. The warrior himself became legendary and symbolic in the years of colonization as well as during the events that formed the United States (Linenthal, p. 3).
There are different types of warriors as well—in early history it was the figure on horseback, or the “Chevalier,” including George Washington; this made him look stately and as a “perfectly balanced warrior” (p. 4). There is another type of warrior—the riflemen. These men are known as the patriots—the ones who fight and have skill that is often “a mixture of the genial and the brutal, the callous and the sentimental, of patriotism and patrioteering, he is the prime type of the nation which is martial but unmilitary” (p. 4). A third type of warriors is the Executioner or “socialized warrior” (p. 4). This type of warrior hero kills because they are on a larger mission, or as if killing is the real mission and due to the technological advances, perhaps they divide America because of their actions.
Washington before Yorktown 1824
http://www.artexpertswebsite.com/pages/artists/peale_rembrandt.php
Washington as the perfectly balanced warrior became a model for the future warrior-presidents. He is remembered for unifying this nation and for embodying the virtues of a hero. It was due to his military acts that a new nation was birthed and for this he is remembered. Washington created the mold of which future warriors must abide by to assume the role as President (p. 16-17).
Many people gave their service and performed heroic acts in the name of Independence.
After the development of military weapons for World War I, the image of the American warrior on horseback changed. The invention of the tank did this, so the tank commander filled the role of this warrior (p. 31). George S. Patton filled this role marvelously as a warrior that Americans now watched. He would have made an excellent commander of cavalry—he was a true warrior, a “fighting machine” (p. 32). He was a complete warrior—exemplifying dedication, leadership, courage, obedience and a sense of duty. Patton knew his role was important to history and he connected what he was doing with what military leaders had done before him. Still though he was accused of being too reckless at times and disregarded his own personal safety. He wanted to lead by “bold example,” but at times his actions caught up with him. Though his image is controversial due to some of his actions and treatment of soldiers, he may very well be “the last total warrior in America” (p. 43-45).
The riflemen image, or the volunteer warrior, earned his image during colonial times. These volunteers were nothing like the mercenaries in Europe. These volunteers showed personal courage and dedication to freedom and patriotism (p. 48). These warriors, though not professional were still dedicated to mission, protecting others, and were ready to give the ultimate sacrifice (p. 49). These warriors remained nameless throughout many battles and wars, but still have impacted the symbolism of what America calls a warrior in a mighty way (p. 49).
The minutemen were the first volunteer warriors in America—the minutemen were composed of lawyers, poor farmers, old soldiers, and more. They wore civilian garb, yet assumed the attributes of a warrior in a minutes time. These minutemen sacrificed everything during the Revolutionary War, and it was their example that many would follow during the Civil War. This model during the Revolutionary War led many soldiers to join the Civil War to “save the independence that had been won by their forefathers” (p. 65).
The mechanization of warfare led to mass deaths and this Americans had to come to grips with—and it was difficult. Could America connect with thousands slaughtered on a battlefield? America continued to see all those who died in mass as heroes. The sacrifice that soldiers gave at battles such as Gettysburg showed that America had people willing to die for their country—for their country to be reborn. The massive number of deaths on battlefields would happen in the later battles of the Civil War as well as the world wars and Vietnam.
America now had to understand how to cope with the mass deaths, and even with the invention of the nuclear weapon, America had to understand how to deal with extinction (p. 75). Many asked the question: Were American soldiers still heroes if they could now kill by remote controls? Some saw this new type of warfare as compromise; the soldier was no longer a hero, but others did not see the new technology as an evil but rather as a way to increase the deaths of the enemy and end the war sooner. The perception of the warrior suffered though through these advances—the warrior image would change because the nature of warfare was changing (p. 90).
World War 1 led to this change in the image of the warrior—Americans symbolically saw the warrior in a reduced view—the warrior was now just inside a machine and his sacrifice was useless and meaningless (p. 94). However, America’s involvement in this war was seen as a crusade, which kept the image of the warrior somewhat alive. Still most saw this warrior as a worker—as someone who had a job to do and to carry out, with the help of a machine. America entered this war to fight a villain—that villain was Germany. America crusaded for human rights and against a foreign enemy, and to preserve democracy in Europe, so that in turn democracy could survive in America (p. 98).
Posters printed in Life magazine portrayed the First World War “as a shroud of death, a devil raised from hell”—and America entered the war to redeem the world and sacrifice was noble (p. 104). War pictures though were no longer picturesque—soldiers fought on land, sea, and in the air—and they tried to blend in, and hide behind machines; all images had no connection to images of the past (p. 105).
The images mostly portrayed were that of destruction—in the trenches, there was death everywhere. There were images of “trees rotting, houses rotting, crops rotting, machines rotting, horses rotting, men rotting” all around on the western front during World War I and these images shocked Americans. The image of the warrior himself evolved—he was part of a machine and was pictured with gas masks—yet his heroism was still present. The mass heroism present during this world war is honored through monuments, such as the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier (p. 112). In the words of President Harding “we do know the glory of his death. He died for his country, and greater devotion hath no man than this” (p. 112).
The warrior is responsible for the birth, rebirth, and preservation of a nation. During World War II, the image of the hero now changed to “homely heroes” because these heroes became patriotic models (p. 118). These warriors still had the virtues of courage and self-sacrifice and were capable of victory “because of the power of the American ideals which inspired them” (p. 119). This world war portrayed soldiers again as if on a crusade, a moral mission, and their courage credited to the classic American courage (p. 120). This war was a different kind of crusade—the soldiers carried through showing heroism because it was the right thing to do—it was their social responsibility (p. 121). The G.I. was ready to sacrifice his life for his country, but he was not the only hero of this war—there were other soldiers—the airmen, the workers, the civilian soldiers called to duty.
The enemy was portrayed in a subhuman way during World War II. The enemies were simply to be killed, but the effects of total war and murder impacted the image of the hero. Now the hero’s image changed from warrior into executioner. The warrior was now changing from having his traditional role just as the image of the war itself was changing to be seen as barren and wasteful (p. 135). “The warrior became passive, a victim in a military machine” (p. 135).
The use of the atomic bomb also affected the way that Americans viewed warriors and war itself. The nuclear age and the technological warfare led to the demise of the warrior as a heroic figure since the warrior would not need to make a sacrifice or show bravery with the possibility of nuclear destruction (p. 143).
Soldiers during the Vietnam War faced alienation and feelings of absurdity (p. 146). The nature of warfare changed—Americans were fighting on ground they were not aware of and their enemy set traps and ambushes. Even the soldiers felt they were not living up to the nature of former warriors. The warriors were concerned and disillusioned about their mission—there was a clash between the historical American war hero and the reality of the war in Vietnam (p. 152). The My Lai massacre that occurred brought about worst fears about the war going on in Vietnam. American soldiers were seen as executioners, even though they had been following orders and were doing what soldiers were trained to do—kill (p. 156-157). The deaths of the My Lai victims were symbolic of the “barren nature of all death in modern warfare, especially in Vietnam” (p. 157). The pictures of the massacre led American’s to see their soldiers as rotten and there was no way to depict these events with heroic ideas—instead this event led to the fall of the hero and G.I’s were seen as “baby-killers” (p. 159).
There was never a sense of appropriate ending to the Vietnam War. There were no final victories, no last stands, and the mission was not fulfilled. Furthermore, “warrior sacrifice was often perceived as a payment for American guilt” (p. 164). Warriors returned home alone and the nation was divided about the American mission in the world. As this war moves further into the past, the attitude of people has changed—the veteran is now capable of being honorable and heroic for his duty and sacrifice, no matter what the mission may have been (p. 166).
Below are several links with famous military leaders:
http://militaryhistory.about.com/od/leaderspioneers/u/peopleplaces.htm
http://www.history.com/photos/axis-military-leaders#world-war-ii-political-leaders
Objectives
This unit is intended for students in the 8th, but could be modified for a 5th grade classroom as 5th graders also study American History. As a middle school English and Social Studies teacher I know this unit will allow my students the opportunity to study art, photographs and images of the past. The assignments in this unit can be a part of their English, Writing, Social Studies and Art grades.
The objectives of the unit will include the following:
- To better understand how war has affected our country
- To examine military conflicts and to look at their causes, conduct and impact on society
- To study famous military leaders of America
- To explore and compare and contrast photographs and images associated with war and to interpret these images using critical thinking skills
- To critically evaluate pieces of art and images using a complex vocabulary
- To find themes, genres, and points of view associated with the images of war